NFL Supplemental Draft Most Notable Picks

Sorsby’s scandal puts spotlight on supplemental draft

Brendan Sorsby was supposed to be Texas Tech’s next high-profile quarterback. The former Indiana and Cincinnati passer arrived with size, mobility and expectations in the Big 12. Instead, a gambling scandal and an NCAA eligibility ruling have pushed him off the college stage. Now his future runs through one of the NFL’s least understood avenues: the supplemental draft.

RELATED: Top 20 College Athletes With The Highest NIL Valuations
RELATED: The 2026 NFL Draft’s 10 Biggest What-Ifs

What the NFL supplemental draft is

The NFL supplemental draft is a mid-summer option for players who become eligible after the regular draft. Prospects usually land there after they unexpectedly lose college eligibility through academics, discipline or new rulings. Teams submit bids using future draft picks in a weighted order. Win a player with a fourth-round bid and you forfeit that pick in the next regular draft. For front offices, it is a calculated gamble on talent that slipped outside the normal process.

RELATED | The NFL’s Other Draft: Inside the Supplemental Draft and How It Works

Why Sorsby is headed there

Sorsby’s case intensified when details of his betting history became public. He acknowledged placing numerous sports wagers, including bets on Indiana football while on the roster. The NCAA ruled him ineligible and denied efforts to restore his status.
A brief court win offered hope, but public and conference pressure quickly closed that door. With his college career effectively over, the supplemental draft has become his only realistic path forward.

That path is not entirely lonely. Over the years, the supplemental draft has produced Pro Bowlers, Hall of Famers and high-risk bets that never paid off. Sorsby now joins a controversial lineage as the league again weighs whether this quiet process can still deliver value.

Here are the most notable supplemental draft selections in NFL history.

Bernie Kosar

• 1985, Round 1, Cleveland Browns
• Career passing: 23,301 yards, 124 TD, 87 INT; 81.8 passer rating; 108 starts

Cris Carter

• 1987, Round 4, Philadelphia Eagles
• Career receiving: 1,101 receptions, 13,899 yards, 130 TD; 8 Pro Bowls; Hall of Fame

Brian Bozworth

• 1987, Round 1, Seattle Seahawks
• Career defense: 24 games, all starts; career cut short by shoulder injury; 1987 All‑Rookie Team

Josh Gordon

• 2012, Round 2, Cleveland Browns
• Career receiving (NFL only): 220 receptions, 3,826 yards, 19 TD; led NFL with 1,646 receiving yards in 2013

Terrelle Pryor

• 2011, Round 3, Oakland Raiders
• Career passing: 1,994 yards, 9 TD, 12 INT; 3–7 record as starting QB;
  Career receiving: 79 receptions, 1,071 yards, 4 TD

Steve Walsh

• Supplemental draft: 1989, Round 1, Dallas Cowboys
• Career passing: 7,875 yards, 40 TD, 50 INT; 20–18 record as starter; 3 playoff starts (1–2)

Ahmad Brooks

• Supplemental draft: 2006, Round 3, Cincinnati Bengals
• Career defense: 145 games, 104 starts; 350 tackles, 53.5 sacks; 1 Pro Bowl

Bobby Humphrey

• Supplemental draft: 1989, Round 1, Denver Broncos
• Career rushing: 2,857 yards, 15 rushing TD in 51 games; 1 Pro Bowl (1991)

Rob Moore

• Supplemental draft: 1990, Round 1, New York Jets
• Career receiving: 628 receptions, 9,368 yards, 49 TD; 2 Pro Bowls; led NFL with 1,584 receiving yards in 1997

Jalen Thompson

• Supplemental draft: 2019, Round 5, Arizona Cardinals
• Career defense (through 2025 season): 78 games; 400‑plus tackles, multiple sacks, 9 INT, 30‑plus passes defended (league stats to date)

Jamal Williams

• Supplemental draft: 1998, Round 2, San Diego Chargers
• Career defense: 164 games, 138 starts; 443 tackles, 13 sacks, 4 forced fumbles, 3 fumble recoveries; 3 Pro Bowls, 2 First‑Team All‑Pro